5 Website Mistakes Christian Creatives Make (and How to Fix Them with Grace)

You’ve prayed over your message, refined your offer, and said “yes” to the work God has called you to do. But then comes the hard part: communicating that clearly online.

A website can be a powerful tool — or a quiet barrier — depending on how it’s built.

Here are five common mistakes I often see Christian creatives and entrepreneurs make with their websites, along with gentle ways to realign and move forward.

1. Using Vague or Generic Copy

Your message is unique — but if your website sounds like everyone else’s, visitors won’t feel that difference.

Common Mistakes:

  • Taglines like “Empowering women everywhere” with no context
  • Paragraphs full of buzzwords but little clarity
  • No real sense of what you offer, who you serve, or why it matters

Fix it with grace:
Start with clarity, not cleverness. Speak directly to the person you’re called to serve. Let your voice reflect your mission — not just a marketing formula.

2. Relying on Outdated or Mismatched Branding

When your visuals don’t match the tone of your message, it creates dissonance. Even if people can’t name what feels off, they feel it.

Common Mistakes:

  • Clashing fonts and colors
  • Stock images that feel impersonal
  • A mood that doesn’t match the tone of your ministry or business

Fix it with grace:
Choose branding that reflects your purpose and the people you’re trying to reach. This doesn’t mean “trendy” — it means intentional.

3. Ignoring Mobile and User Experience

More than half of your visitors are likely browsing on a phone. If your site isn’t mobile-friendly or easy to navigate, they may leave before they even see what you do.

Common Mistakes:

  • Text that’s hard to read on mobile
  • Menus that don’t work well
  • Slow loading times or cluttered layouts

Fix it with grace:
View your website from your phone and walk through it like a visitor. Is it easy to read, tap, and scroll? If not, it may be time for a refresh.

4. Forgetting About SEO (Search Engine Optimization)

It’s not just about being online — it’s about being found. Even faith based businesses benefit from foundational SEO.

Common Mistakes:

  • No page titles or descriptions
  • Vague or repetitive headings that don’t describe the page content
  • Blog posts without keywords or structure

Fix it with grace:
Use clear, descriptive page titles and headings. Think about what your audience might be searching for — and speak to that. A little intentional structure can make a big difference.

5. Not Pointing Visitors Toward a Next Step

Your website should be more than beautiful — it should be a guide. Every page should help visitors know where to go next.

Common Mistakes:

  • No call to action
  • Buttons that say “Learn More” with no clear outcome
  • A blog or About page that ends with… nothing

Fix it with grace:
Help your visitor know what to do next — whether that’s downloading a free resource, booking a consult, or reading another blog post. Don’t leave them wandering.

Keep it Simple and Clear

A clear, straightforward website makes it easy for visitors to understand who you are and how you or your business can help. When your message and design work together, your website becomes more than a digital space, it becomes an open invitation.

If you’re making one (or more) of these mistakes, you’re not alone. They’re incredibly common — and fixable with grace.


Want help aligning your website with your message?
Explore custom design services →

Similar Posts